It was December 28, 1998,
when I first met Bernie. I received a
call December 17,1998, from a young woman
named Bonnie who seemed very distressed.
She had received my name from the bank
her dad, Bernie, patronized. Bonnie was
wondering if I could help her father. As
Bonnie began telling me her father's
story, I could hear the pain and concern
in her voice. Her father had been
hospitalized in October for a collapsed
lung and then was sent to recuperate at a
local nursing home.
Medicare benefits soon ran out and
would no longer cover her father's stay
at the nursing home. Bernie and his
family were informed he would be required
to pay a daily rate of $100 or leave.
Bernie and his family knew he was not in
a position to pay for the services in the
nursing home. He had only a matter of
days to make other arrangements.
Bernie had six children who lived at
least hundreds of miles away. Since it
was around Thanksgiving, they were having
a hard time making arrangements to get
home to help. Bonnie had contacted the
Department of Social Services, but
according to their assessment, Bernie
made too much money to receive assistance
through the Medicaid program. Bernie's
income was between $1100 to $1200 a
month, barely enough to live in his home,
much less an alternative care setting.
The family was fortunate to meet a county
social worker who truly wanted to help,
even if it could not be financially. She
assisted the family in locating a number
of alternative care homes in other
counties that Bernie could afford. The
family called the approximately 35 homes
on the list the social worker gave them.
The family located a group home in
another county that had an opening and
the admission to the home was under way.
The group home stay proved to be a
deadly one. Bernie was discharged from
the nursing home with a five-day supply
of medication. The family was to obtain
refills of Bernie's medications from the
Veteran's Administration Medical Center
in Madison. Bernie's son from southern
Wisconsin made the long trip to the group
home to take his father to an upcoming
appointment at the VAMC. The medications
were reordered and taken to the pharmacy
to be set up so that the staff in the
group home could administer the
medications to Bernie. Bernie's son then
had to return home to his family and his
business.
Within a week of Bernie's admission to
the group home, he started to grow weaker
and his lungs began to fill with fluid.
Bernie brought it to the attention of the
staff at the group home and even
questioned whether he was getting his
Lasix (water pill). Staff assured him he
was, but he continued to wonder. A few
more days passed and Bernie was feeling
worse. He was barely able to walk, so the
staff provided him a wheelchair to use
until he was feeling better. Bernie
continued to question if his Lasix was
being given to him. The staff and manager
of the home then reviewed his medications
closer this time. They found that in fact
he was not on a water pill. When informed
of this, Bernie was frightened and
explained he had been on the water pill
since his heart surgery in 1976. The
certified nursing assistant working at
the group home did an assessment, but
other than the weakness noted no other
symptoms. After much insistence from
Bernie, the staff finally called the VAMC
to report their findings and to ask for
an appointment, which was made for
December 17, 1998. With the assessment by
the nursing home staff, the VAMC staff
believed he would be fine until then.
Bernie continued to decline over the next
few days.
Following the appointment at the VAMC,
Bernie was given a larger dose of Lasix
to help pull off the extra fluid he was
unable to metabolize out of his system.
Because of the late hour, the medication
was not picked up at the pharmacy in the
VA. Bernie was returned to the group
home. The group home was to receive the
medication via next day mail. Over the
next two to three days, Bernie continued
to grow weaker. He became very concerned
that the Lasix was not working. He
reported it to the staff but the staff
did nothing. Christmas came and went and
still Bernie's condition did not improve.
The evening of December 25, 1998, Bernie
began to request that the staff take him
to the hospital, but they did not. The
next day, Bernie continued to beg the
staff to take him to the hospital and by
4 p.m. the staff did arrange for his
transport to the hospital. He was
admitted for fluid overload, a condition
where the body becomes filled with fluid
that the body cannot get rid of on its
own. It was determined that Bernie had an
extra 30 to 50 pounds of fluid
circulating in his system, taxing his
heart, lungs, kidneys and liver. Bernie
remained hospitalized for two days and
then because of Medicare guidelines, he
was discharged. The group home refused to
readmit him because of his decline in
status, so he was sent home.
This is where I entered the picture.
Bernie was discharged home on December
28, 1998, into a setting that, without my
assistance, he would have surely died.
Bernie received visits from me, a
registered nurse certified in
gerontology, twice a week and more as
needed. I assisted with medication
management and physical assessment and
offered companionship. We also had a
personal care aide visit weekly to assist
with bathing and lunches from Meals on
Wheels were delivered daily. Volunteers
and a good friend did what they could to
help him function.
Why did Bernie have so little in his
time of need? Because he was in a
situation that many older adults fall
into: They have lower to middle incomes
that do not qualify them for aid and have
family members that are not readily
available. A system that is aimed at
helping the elderly and disabled failed
Bernie, like so many others.
With permission of Bernie and his
family, we filed a report with the
Department of Health and Family Services,
which began an immediate investigation.
Though the investigation continues,
preliminary reports find Bernie fell
victim to a Veterans Administration
doctor who made a bad decision to not
continue his Lasix and a group home that
admitted him inappropriately. The
facility was not licensed to provide him
the amount of care he required and the
staff there was not trained to handle his
medical condition.
Bernie died May 27, 1999, only a few
short months after his ordeal began. The
doctors say the incidence of fluid
overload most likely caused Bernie's
heart to be overworked, causing permanent
damage not only to his heart but to his
lungs, liver and kidneys. This also is
known as stage four congestive heart
failure. Months were probably taken off
Bernie's life, as one physician informed
us. Bernie was afraid and did not want to
die alone, so he requested I stay with
him. As he took his final breaths, I
reflected on his story. As Bernie asked
me to, I now share his story with you in
an attempt to put a face to a story that
is all too common to our elderly and
their families.
When Bernie died, he was 79 years old,
just 34 days short of his 80th birthday.
He was a veteran who served in active
duty as a Major in the U.S. Air Force
during World War II. He served in the
reserves for 30 years following the war.
He was a father of six children, a
grandfather of 13 children, a brother and
a good friend to many people.
This is a true story, not unique to
our elderly. Many more stories go untold
and perhaps hidden from our society every
day. Families struggle to find a way to
tell their stories and to get help for
their loved ones. Our systems that are in
place to help our senior citizens and
their families are not perfected and need
further work to make them work in favor
of our aging society. We can no longer
afford to ignore these problems. We need
to address the elder issues of abuse and
neglect in all care settings. We as a
society can make a difference if we join
together as one voice for a common cause,
QUALITY CARE FOR OUR ELDERLY AND
DISABLED IN ALL SETTINGS.